Monday, February 3, 2014

King’s Transition from the Struggle for Black Political Rights to Economic Rights for All to Death by Hatred, 1955-1968

                               
By Emmanuel Konde
       
   Introduction
Having just recently concluded the first phase of the struggle for civil rights by 1965, the second phase of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.’s struggle was consumed by his obsession to obliterate poverty in America. This compelled him to oppose the Vietnam War because he felt that the latter war was distracting attention and detracting resources from the former.  But by opposing the Vietnam War, Dr. King placed himself in the middle of two wars—the war of imperialism abroad and the war on poverty at home. In both wars he sought to dismantle the prevailing order that was supported by significantly powerful groups. By opposing the Vietnam War and advocating for the War on Poverty, Dr. King simultaneously became the enemy of both the political and economic power brokers of America.   
Dr. King’s opposition to the Vietnam War would ultimately result in his assassination in Memphis on April 4, 1968. Whether Dr. King was killed as the result of a conspiracy hatched and executed by political, economic and other hideous forces, as some have speculated, is beyond the capacity of this writer to determine.  Abundantly clear, however, is that the assassination of Dr. King was inextricably connected to his putsch to end the war in Vietnam and redefine the workings of capitalism in American society.  Drawing on his previous success that culminated with the enactment of the Voting Rights Act of 1965, Dr. King transcended race in his pursuit of justice and real freedom for all Americans.  This essay maps out the trajectory of Dr. King’s last year on Earth that witnessed the transition of his struggle from political to economic, his personal transformation from mere man to legend, and his eventual premature death resulting from his sense of conviction and love for America.  But first some background information about his rise to national prominence.

                              Background to the Transition

The 1950s-1960s Civil Rights movement in the United States was first and foremost an intellectual revolution that drew its ethos from a long Western tradition of transforming society with ideas dating back to the Italian humanists of the 13th century.  Humanism spawned the Scientific Revolution of the 17th century, which likewise provided the necessary impetus for the Enlightenment of the 18th century.  Although few activists knew the source of the ideas propagated by Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. during the Civil Rights Movement of the mid-twentieth century, the movement was a direct descendant of the Enlightenment that provided the steam for the American and French revolutions. To this end, Dr. King was a son of the Enlightenment and, like the philosphes of the Enlightenment who came before him, he, too, was an advocate for justice and the advancement of humankind.
Initially ignited by the Montgomery Bus Boycott event, the Civil Rights Movement reached its apogee during the 1963 March on Washington—the largest politically-motivated assemblage of humanity at one place at the same time in America’s history—whose crowning moment came when Dr. King delivered his electrifying and visionary “I have a Dream” speech.  Drawing from the ideas that made the modern Western world and gave birth to the United States of America, Dr. King tailored his words to the social crisis at hand.  His speech penetrated deeply into the soul of America and directly contributed to persuading Congress to pass the civil rights legislation that guaranteed voting rights of the hitherto forgotten Americans of darker hue.  That speech also exposed two interlocking variables about the African American who dared to dream so publicly: (1) the power of persuasion that lurked in the small frame of Dr. King; and (2) the revelation that if he was left unchecked the speaker could pose a formidable challenge to the then extant capitalist economic order in America.
After the signing of the Voting Rights Act by President Lyndon B. Johnson in August 1965, however, it became obvious that some measure of success had been attained.  This success brought some degree of closure to the first phase of the Civil Rights Movement, which was essentially political and involved principally America’s black population.  The need for expansion into the economic sphere to include other impoverished and forgotten Americans—Latinos, Amerindians, poor whites and blacks through articulating and executing a new civil rights agenda—naturally intruded itself.   Whereas the first phase was political, the second was to be economic.  The latter campaign would seek to bring the benefits of the world’s richest nation to all of its citizens.  But was the quest for inclusion of poor whites and minorities into the wealthy white dominated American economic order attainable?  Obviously, this question did seem to matter but Dr. King was progressive enough to understand that the political right to vote was not in and of itself a panacea for freedom. Surely, a homeless and hungry person can hardly be said to be politically free.   To be truly free poor Americans would have to be included in a new social contract that guaranteed them a living wage.  
Dr. King was thus poised to resolve the contradiction arising from the dichotomy in capitalist America between the idealism of political equality and the realism of economic inequality.  Well-versed in the ideas that made America the first nation-state contrived by the human mind, King methodically undertook to tackle this seemingly intractable contradiction by taking up the question of “economic rights” on behalf of the dispossessed American masses.  By embarking on this quest for economic rights for poor Americans, Dr. King placed himself squarely at variance with the established economic interests of the nation.  This essay examines how Dr. King and the Southern Christian Leadership Conference (SCLC) sought to resolve the inherent contradiction between political equality and economic inequality in American society via the medium of the Poor People’s Campaign (PPC) organized by Dr. King himself.

                    The Poor People’s Campaign

On December 4, 1967, Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. announced the “Poor People’s Campaign” (PPC) in Atlanta, Georgia.  At the press conference, Dr. King declared to the reporters there assembled that

The Southern Christian Leadership Conference will lead waves of the nation’s poor and disinherited to Washington, D.C. next spring to demand redress of their grievances by the United States government and to secure at least jobs or income for all.  We will go there, we will demand to be heard, and we will stay until America responds.  If this means forcible repression of our movement we will confront it, for we have done this before.  If this means scorn or ridicule we embrace it, for that is what America’s poor now receive.  If it means jail we accept it willingly, for the millions of poor already are imprisoned by exploitation and discrimination (See “Press conference announcing the Poor People’s Campaign,” Papers of Martin Luther King, Jr.[1]

Barely four years after the successful 1963 Civil Rights March on Washington, this announcement signaled the beginning of the transition of Dr. King’s struggle from political equality among America’s races to some degree of redistribution of wealth among America’s classes, from the haves to the have-nots.  This transition was bold in conception and equally bold in its proposed method of execution.  It sent off alarm bells, which rang in the ears of the traditional “liberal consensus”—comprised of blue-collar democrats, a collection of liberal intellectuals and the press, policy makers, progressive-minded businessmen, church leaders, and students—that had lent support to the 1963 Civil Rights March on Washington.
The proposed PPC was in fact progressive in its orientation but, unlike the African American civil rights struggle that was embraced by many Americans, it ran counter to the philosophy of the “liberal consensus” enshrined in the belief that “American capitalism was a revolutionary force for social change, that economic growth was supremely good because it obviated the need for redistribution and social conflict, that class had no place in American politics.”[2] In the eyes of those whites who had supported the March on Washington in August 1963, the Civil Rights movement was in accordance with, and an affirmation of, the liberal faith.  Nothing in the ideas of the movement at that stage seemed to contradict the liberal orthodoxy.  The political phase of the Civil Rights Movement’s goal to integrate blacks more fully into white society was championed by the liberal consensus, stretching from the White House, labor, churches, and intellectuals, to sectors of the business community.  There was hope, as late as the fall of 1963, that integration could be achieved without posing a challenge to the basic structure of white society.[3]
As long as white liberals controlled the agenda of the civil rights struggle, all was well.  But no sooner the SCLC began to articulate a course of action at variance with the “liberal consensus” than the liberal reaction set in.  Professor Manning Marable has noted that “effective power is never exercised solely by a single race, but by a dominant social class. Thus Black political movements are simultaneously movements that seek to restructure or radically transform class relations.”[4]
Dr Martin Luther King understood just too well what needed to be done to alter the negative sides of both race and class relations in American society.  Where he might have miscalculated was in the timing of the launching of his Poor People’s Campaign.  At the height of the Vietnam War, Dr. King’s simultaneous opposition to the war and his linking of the Vietnam War to the War on Poverty in America meant that he was not only alienating the liberal consensus that had been instrumental in the civil rights gains, but also that the hostile right could now find common ground with liberals in their opposition to the PPC.

             Vietnam War and the Fracturing of the Civil Rights Coalition

Following the Meredith, Mississippi March in 1966, the slogan “black power” became a distinct philosophy that contrasted sharply with King’s ideas of integration.  In 1965, national issues arising from the Vietnam War coupled with African American frustration with respect to a perceived stagnation of goals and progress in the movement confounded King and the SCLC staff.[5]  When on March 2, 1965 President Lyndon B. Johnson launched “Operation Rolling Thunder” that occasioned the bombing of North Vietnam, in a speech at Howard University Dr. King openly questioned U.S. policy in Vietnam and called for a negotiated settlement.  Not wishing to provoke Johnson for fear that the president might turn against the Civil Rights movement, Dr. King exercised caution and did not fully rebuke U.S. efforts in Southeast Asia.

Like King, other civil rights leaders were well aware of the politics of collaboration that entailed support for the black civil rights struggle in exchange for black silence on the Vietnam War.  Consequently, Whitney Young of the Urban League noted that “Johnson needs a consensus.  If we are not with him on the Vietnam War, then he is not going to be with us on Civil Rights,”[6]  When the Student Non-Violence Coordinating Committee (SNCC) publicly denounced the Vietnam War in 1966, Dr. King neither issued a statement of support nor did he join the rising chorus of Civil Rights leaders condemning the SNCC.  Speaking for the Urban League, Young stated that his group would renounce Civil Rights organizations that “formally adopted black power as a program, or which [tied] domestic rights with the Vietnam conflict.”  Roy Wilkins of the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP) similarly remarked on the SNCC’s position against the war by labeling them as “only one of many civil rights groups,” and added that their statement was “not the statement of other groups of what is loosely called the Civil Rights movement.”[7]
                Dr. King was slow in condemning the war in Vietnam, even as he progressively moved toward a position that coupled the war with the social spending programs at home.  Accordingly, in April 1966 Dr. King and the SCLC board passed a resolution condemning the Vietnam War.  In August of that same year at the SCLC annual convention that met in Augusta, the organization called for immediate and unilateral de-escalation of the Vietnam conflict.  Concerned with the plight of the poor, King proposed three initiatives for the organization during an SCLC strategy session in October 1966.  One of these called for the organizing of America’s impoverished towards a “crusade to reform society in order to realize economic and social justice.”  In November of that year, King spoke at Howard University and told his audience that African Americans needed to confront “basic issues between the privileged and the underprivileged.”  While lending his support to Byard Rustin and A. Philip Randolph’s 1966 “Freedom Budget” that asked for a guaranteed annual wage,[8] King’s transition from civil rights for African Americans to human rights for all impoverished Americans culminated with his speech against the Vietnam War at Riverside Church in New York City on April 4, 1967.
Entitled “Beyond Vietnam: A Time to Break the Silence,” King noted with particular emphasis the link between the war in Vietnam and the War on Poverty in America that,
Since I am a preacher by trade, I suppose it is not surprising that I have seven major reasons for bringing Vietnam into the field of my moral vision. There is at the outset a very obvious and almost facile connection between the war in Vietnam and the struggle I, and others, have been waging in America. A few years ago there was a shining moment in that struggle. It seemed as if there was a real promise of hope for the poor -- both black and white -- through the poverty program. There were experiments, hopes, new beginnings. Then came the buildup in Vietnam and I watched the program broken and eviscerated as if it were some idle political plaything of a society gone mad on war, and I knew that America would never invest the necessary funds or energies in rehabilitation of its poor so long as adventures like Vietnam continued to draw men and skills and money like some demonic destructive suction tube. So I was increasingly compelled to see the war as an enemy of the poor and to attack it as such. [9]
Consequently, by Dr. King who had by 1967 concluded that ending the war in Vietnam was a moral imperative, and thus could draw a clear link between the war in Vietnam and the need for a real “war on poverty” at home.[10]  The proposed PCC, at least for Dr. King and the SCLC, was an appropriate strategy for winning the “war on poverty” at home.  To this end, the quest for African American civil rights was effectively subordinated to the human rights of America’s poor of all races.

                   Strategizing for the Poor People’s Campaign

After the passage and signing of the civil rights legislation in 1964, the emergence of Black Power and abating of urban riots the previous summer, the leadership of the Southern Christian Leadership Conference met in November 1967 to discuss a new direction of their movement.  From these discussions sprung the idea for the Poor People’s Campaign.  As leader of the SCLC, Dr. Martin Luther King was barely 38 years old in 1967. His calling to uplift America’s poor and disinherited may well have been providential. Yet he was by no means oblivious to the difficulty of the task that lay ahead.  King knew that a multi-racial poor people’s movement aimed at redistributing America’s wealth might prove more daunting to build than the non-violent tactics employed by blacks with a uniform history of suffering to end legal segregation in the South.  King was obviously moving toward a new direction, a direction few Americans were willing to veer toward in 1967.  Although many Americans were opposed to the Vietnam War without equating it with issues of class and poverty in America, Dr. King believed that there was an intrinsic relationship between the federal expenditure on an “immoral war” and the paucity of funds to spend on President Johnson “war on poverty.”  In an interview with Jose Yglesias, “King explained that although the cost to the nation of wiping out poverty had not been reduced to a dollar figure, the war in Vietnam—this unjust and immoral war,’ as he always characterized it—cannot be waged if the campaign’s demands are met.”[11]
                The proposed PPC march on Washington was planned for early April 1968.  The SCLC was to organize people to move on Washington from ten major cities and five rural areas.  It was to be no ordinary march, “no mere one-day march in Washington but a trek to the nation’s capital by suffering and outraged citizens who will go to stay until some definite and positive action is taken to provide jobs and income for the poor.”[12]  The campaign was to entail a massive dislocation without destroying life or property, but consciously designed to dramatize the situation, and “channelize the very legitimate and understandable rage of the ghetto….”[13]
                Expectedly, King’s call for a poor people’s campaign—which was essentially a coalition based on class and race that called for militant non-violent confrontation—did not sit well with members of the liberal establishment.  The reluctance of many Americans to embrace this approach was understandable.  Americans have always been averse to class wars.  They pride themselves as a classless society in which the greater majority belong in the amorphous middle class.  Dr. King’s “poor people’s campaign” therefore posed a direct challenge to an American myth that articulated a non-existent economic equality that drew its ethos from America’s democratic principle of political equality.  It is no wonder that members of the liberal press, who had hitherto supported the Civil Rights movement, immediately took to expressing their discontent with King’s “poor people’s campaign.”  A New York Times editorial responded to Dr. King’s new campaign as follows:

Like the threat to ‘close down’ Federal induction centers, Dr. Martin Luther King’s plan to seek ‘massive dislocation’ of the national capital violates the principles of responsible protest.  Dr. King insists that the massive civil disobedience campaign he plans in Washington next April will be nonviolent.  But his proclaimed goal of massive dislocation belies Dr. King’s profession of peaceful intent.  If such a result were achieved, by whatever means, it would probably involve some overt violence and it would certainly violate the rights of thousands of Washingtonians and the interests of millions of Americans.  This is one more case in which the means are not justified by the end.”[14]

In other words, the New York Times was opposed to King’s “poor people’s campaign” and its opposition was also class-based.  It feared that the rabble of society, if brought in huge numbers to Washington, D.C., might end up resorting to violence.  Such violence would disrupt the accustomed way of life of the bourgeoisie who had worked hard for what they had and were not ready to share their wealth with America’s poor.
                For what it is worth, the leadership of the SCLC was very progressive in its thinking than many Americans.  The late-Rev. Hosea Williams, the PPC’s “political action” director, had captured the essence of this new orientation of SCLC rather eloquently, when he accurately analyzed the situation at hand thusly:

We will never get free by eliminating racism or bringing about integration.  If black people were able to eliminate every aspect of racism and integrate every aspect of American life, we would not be free. Black folks will never be free until we have our fair share of the economy.  We live not in a political society, nor in a social society, nor a religious society, we live in an economic society.  So we had to launch a movement to gain our fair share of the economy.[15]

                      Contextualizing the Struggle in Time Prespective
To understand why Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. was assassinated short of unveiling the actual actors who orchestrated his assassination, we need to place the struggle he led within the context of his  times as well as the then prevailing national political and economic values.  The United States of America was founded on laissez capitalism, which from the onset established a high wall separating the government and the economy.  Over time Americans have come to believe that capitalism provided an avenue of upward mobility to all, hence capitalism obviates the need for redistribution of wealth through socialist experiments.  Consequently, Dr. King’s “Poor People’s Campaign” posed a challenge that portended a viable threat to the prevailing American economic ideology of laissez-faire capitalism. By proposing a redistribution of wealth in a country that did not espouse such an idea and in fact felt that such an idea was contrary to American values, Dr. King effectively placed himself in direct opposition to the guardians of the American system. 
Timing is important in everything that human beings do.  The timing of the “Poor People’s Campaign” could not have come at a less propitious moment.  The 1960s saw the United States and the Soviet Union embroiled in a Cold War, a period of global tension brought to the fore by two hostile camps representing two contending economic ideologies of capitalism and communism.  Each of the two major powers were determined to spread their ideology across the globe.  In the ideologically-ridden atmosphere of the time, one was either for or against the American Way.  It was therefore not the content of King’s ideas that mattered as much as how he was perceived by those who mattered.
Granted, the contradiction between political equality and economic inequality within the context of a democratic society is yet to be resolved.  Whether it was King’s desire to force this resolution on American society is not clear.  What is clear is that for good or ill, Dr. King had made himself the ultimate anti-establishment man on two important fronts: his opposition to the Vietnam War and his proposal to alter the economic arrangement of American society.  Never before in American history has an ordinary black preacher risen to such prominence; never has a black-skinned American been so able to galvanize American citizens to mass action with mere words.  An exceptionally well-educated man who understood the power of Western revolutionary ideas and knew how to use them, Martin Luther King, Jr. was deemed a dangerous man who had to be eliminated. Incidentally, his campaigns were executed during a troubling period of political assassinations in America’s history.
The 1960s was a period in America’s political history in which political assassinations were rampant.  One cannot but wonder whether these assassinations were not linked to the Civil Rights aspirations of African Americans, especially when viewed from the vantage point of the individuals who were assassinated. Medgar Wylie Evers was assassinated on June 12, 1963; President John F. Kennedy was assassinated in November 1963; Malcolm X in 1965; Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. on April 4, 1968; and Robert Kennedy on June 5, 1968.  All these men were involved with the civil rights movements in varying degrees, either as activists or sympathizers.  Whether the plots to eliminate these men were in any way connected, whether their deaths were the result of a concerted conspiracy, whether they were killed as a result of the convergence of hatred against African American aspirations, is not clear.  But all five men were all killed within a time span of five years.

                    The Man Who Defied Death

Martin Luther King, Jr. was barely 26 years old when he was catapulted to the position of spokesman charged with articulating the aspirations of African Americans in the Jim Crow South.  There are few instances in history when a man so young has been invested with such a heavy burden.  Martin was neither the man for the time nor the man for the responsibility that was suddenly thrust on him.  He was too young to shoulder the great American burden of racism more than 300 years in the making.  The times caught up with him, entangled him, and thus the young preacher, unable to disentangle himself from that web of historical destiny, was swept by the whirlwind of his calling.  His people called him to service, and Martin answered their call. Barely thirteen  years (1955-1968) into the mission that destiny had ordained for him, the eloquent and compelling young preacher’s promising life was cut short by deep, ingrained hatred.  Today, however, we cannot but ask these questions: Why was Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. killed?  And why did the Civil Rights Movement die with him, even though his legacy lives on?

Chronology of the Poor People’s Campaign (PPC)
November 1967
  • Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. and the staff of SCLC met to discuss the direction of the Civil Rights Movement after the passage and signing of civil rights legislation, the emergence of Black Power, and the urban riots of the previous summer.
  • The SCLC decided to launch the Poor People’s Campaign, a movement to address economic equalities with nonviolent direct action.
Dec. 4, 1967
  • Dr. King announced  the Poor People’s Campaign at a Press conference in Atlanta, indicating that it will be set in motion in early April 1968
Measure of the PPC
  • The SCLC planned the PPC to be the “second phase” of the civil rights struggle, involving poor blacks, American Indians, Mexicans, Puerto Ricans, and poor whites. It was to be the most massive campaign of civil disobedience, causing complete dislocation in Washington, D.C. in order to dramatize and compel government to address the issue of poverty in American society.
April 4, 1968
  • Unfortunately, Dr. King was assassinated on April 4,, 1968 in Memphis, Tennessee, where he was attending a rally for the city’s sanitation workers’ strike
May 12 – June 19, 1968
  • After Dr. King’s death leadership of the SCLC passed on to the Rev. Ralph Abernathy.  The King family and SCLC leadership decided to carry out the PPC campaign in honor of the slain leader. On May 12, the first wave of demonstrators descended on Washington, D.C.
  • A week later Resurrection City, a settlement of tents and shacks to house the protesters, was built on the Washington Mall.
  • Demonstrators were sent out to various government agencies to protest and spread the message of the campaign.
Demands of the Campaign
Specifically, the campaign requested a $30 billion anti-poverty package that would include
  • A commitment to full employment
  • A guaranteed annual income measure
  • Increased construction of low income housing
Ineffectiveness of the Campaign
  • Ralph Abernathy lacked the inspirational qualities of King
  • The national press was opposed to PPC
  • Robert Kennedy was assassinated
  • Overwhelming number of protesters (7,000 at its peak) undermined the campaign’s effectiveness
  • Failing to move legislators to action, the PPC closed camp on June 19, 1968.




[2] Geoffrey Hodgson, America in Our Time: From World War II to Nixon What Happened and Why (New York: Random House, 1978), p. 89.

[3] Ibid., p.179.

[4] Black American Politics: From the Washington Marches to Jesse Jackson (London: Verso, 1985), p. vii.

[5] Robert T. Chase, “Class Resurrection: The Poor People’s Campaign of 1968 and Resurrection City.”Essays in History. Volume Forty. Corcoran Department of History, University of Virginia, 1998), p. 3.

[6] Adam Fairclough, To Redeem the Soul of America: The Southern Christian Leadership Conference and martin Luther King, Jr. (Athens: University of Georgia Press, 1978), pp. 23-25; Young quoted in James Forman, The Making of a Black Revolutionary (New York: Macmillian, 1972), p. 309.

[7] Young and Wilkins, quoted in Henry Hampton and Steve Fayer (eds.), Voices of Freedom: An Oral History of the Civil Rights movement from the 1950s Through the 1980s (New York: Bantam Books, 1990), p. 339.

[8] David Garrow, Bearing the Cross: Martin Luther King Jr., and the Southern Christian Leadership Conference (New York: William Morrow, 1986), pp. 539-540.

[9] See “Beyond Vietname: A Time to Break the Silence” By martin Luther King, 4 April 1967. BRC-News list at http://www.ssc.msu.edu/-sw/mlk/brksInc.htm

[10] Chase, “Class Resurrection,” p. 3.

[11] Jose Yglesias, New York Times Magazine, March 31, 1967.

[12] Press conference announcing the Poor People’s Campaign. December 4, 1967, Atlanta, Georgia. Papers of Martin Luther King, Jr., p. 1.

[13] Ibid., pp. 2-3.

[14] New York Times Editorial, “The Responsibility of Dissent,” December 6, 1967, p. 46.

[15] Reverend Hosea Williams, interview with Robert T. Chase.  See Chase, “Class Resurrection,” p. 5
***Dr. Emmanuel Konde is a Professor of History, Political Science & Public Administration at Albany State University in Albany, Georgia***

NATIONALITY LAW IN CAMEROUN: AN ALTERNATIVE PERSPECTIVE


By Martin Tumasang



                       Introduction
     The Prince Ndedi Eyango saga has brought the issue of Nationality to prominence amongst the diaspora community and the local press in Cameroon. I have argued with good authority on constitutional interpretation and applied various principles to justify my interpretation (understanding) of the laws to avoid a discriminatory outcome, where a foreigner might acquire Cameroon nationality without losing his foreign nationality but a Cameroonian cannot acquire foreign nationality and preserve his Cameroonian nationality. I have put a robust argument in favour of an interpretation that is based on equity, fairness and non-discrimination. But is my interpretation correct?.
                 Analogous Nigerian Situation
     In order to answer the above question, it is pertinent to revisit the issue and make sure my conclusions are not non sequitur. This approach might give a solatium to those who had opposing views on the issue. I would be a penitus insitus liar if I say I do not doubt my conclusions and that I do not find myself in a non redevable position. Without fear of being excoriated for my intellectual desquamation or peregrination, it is important to explain the source of my present doubt.

     The most propitious place to start is the Nigerian Supreme Court in the case of Global Excellence Communication Limited vs. Mr. Donald Duke, Nigerian Supreme Court SC313/2006. Donald Duke was the Executive Governor of Cross River State and Section 308 of the 1999 Nigerian constitution stipulated that:
(1) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in this Constitution, but subject to subsection (2) of this section,
(a) No civil or criminal proceedings shall be instituted or continued against a person to whom this section applies during his period of office;
(b) A person to whom this section applies shall not be arrested or imprisoned during that period either in pursuance of the process of any court or otherwise; and
(c) No process of any court requiring or compelling the appearance of a person to whom this section applies, shall be applied for or issued; Provided that in ascertaining whether any period of limitation has expired for the purpose of any proceedings against a person to whom this section applies, no account shall be taken of his period of office.…..
(3) This section applies to a person holding the office of President or Vice-President, Governor or Deputy Governor

     So, in essence, no one can sue a President, Governor etc. No criminal or civil action that started before one became governor can be continued nor can new criminal or civil action be brought against a governor whilst still a Governor. The constitution is silent on whether a Governor can actually sue someone in his personal capacity whilst bstill on seat as Governor. If this is possible, it would be discriminatory i.e. the Governor can sue someone but you cannot sue him. That would be a terrible law and discriminatory outcome if the constitution was interpreted in that manner.

     The above is analogous to the Cameroon Nationality law where the law is silent on whether a foreigner acquiring Cameroonian nationality has to renounce his foreign nationality.
So how did the Supreme Court interpret the constitution in the case of the Nigerian Governor? I am conscious of the constitution interpretation rules developed in A-G of Bendel State vs A-G of the Federation & ors (1981) 9 S.C (Reprint) 1 at 78 - 79, where Obaseki, J.S.C. stated the principles guiding the court in interpreting or constructing the provisions of the constitution to include the following:-
"(1) Effect should be given to every word.
(2) A construction nullifying a specific clause will not be given to the Constitution unless absolutely required by the context.
(3) A Constitutional power cannot be used by way of condition to attain unconstitutional result.
(4) The language of the Constitution where clear and unambiguous must be given its plain evident meaning.
(5) The Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria is an organic scheme of government to be dealt with as an entirety; a particular provision cannot be dissevered from the rest of the Constitution.
(6) While the language of the Constitution does not change, the changing circumstances of a progressive society for which it was designed yield new and fuller import to the meaning.
(7) A Constitutional provision should not be construed so as to defeat its evident purpose.
(8) Under a Constitution conferring specific powers, a particular power must be granted or it cannot be exercised.
(9) Delegation by the National Assembly of its essential legislative function is precluded by the Constitution (Section 58(4)
and section 4(1))
(10) Words are the common signs that mankind make use of to declare their intention one to another and when the words of a man express his meaning plainly and distinctly and perfectly, there is no occasion to have recourse to any other means of interpretation.
(11) The principles upon which the Constitution was established rather than the direct operation or literal meaning of the words used, measure the purpose and scope of its provisions.
(12) Words of the Constitution are therefore not to be read with stultifying narrowness."It is with the above principles in mind that the provisions of section 308 of the 1999 Constitution will be interpreted. However, it is settled law that the duty of the courts is simply to interpret the law or Constitution as made by the legislature or the framers of the Constitution. It is therefore not the Constitutional responsibility of the judiciary to make laws neither can it amend the laws made by the legislature. It must therefore be borne in mind always that courts cannot amend the Constitution neither can they change the words used in crafting it. I had earlier reproduced the provisions of section 308 of the 1999 Constitution in this judgment and it is my considered view that the provisions are very clear and unambiguous. It is now settled that:"

     Having stated the above general principles, how did the court decide?. Can the constitution be interpreted to allow the Governor to go around suing people when no one can sue him?. Can the courts allow such discrimination?

     The Nigerian Supreme Court held in the case where Donald Duke (governor of Cross River) instituted a liable case against a newspaper in his personal capacity that “..From the words used by the framers of section 308 of the 1999 Constitution, it is clear that their intention is explicitly to confer absolute immunity on the respondent and the others therein mentioned without a corresponding disability on them to the exercise of their rights to institute actions in their personal capacities in any relevant court of law for redress during their tenure of office, as in the instant case. The above view finds support in the dictum of Ayoola, J.S.C. in Tinubu vs I.M.B. Securities PLC (supra) at 721 - 722 where the following view is expressed:-"Thirdly, I am unable to construe a provision of the Constitution that granted an immunity such as section 308(1) as also constituting a disability on the person granted immunity when there is not provision to that effect, either expressly or by necessary implication in the enactment. If makers of the Constitution had wanted to prohibit a person holding the offices stated in section 308 from instituting or continuing action instituted against any other person during his period of office, nothing would have been easier than to provide expressly that: 'no civil or criminal proceeding shall be instituted against any person by a person to whom this section applies during his period of office and no civil or criminal proceedings shall be instituted or continued against such a person during his period in office' Or in like terms. The makers of the Constitution in their wisdom did not so provide."I entirely agree with the above dictum and adopt same as mine in this judgment. I consequently reject the contrary dicta of Karibi-Whyte and Kalgo, JJSC in the case of Tinubu vs I.M.B. Securities P.L.C at 708 and 718 cited and relied upon by learned counsel for the appellants as the same are not in accord with the clear intention of the framers of section 308 of the 1999 Constitution. I also do not agree with the submission of learned counsel for the appellants that a confirmation of the interpretation of section 308 of the 1999 Constitution by the lower court would lead to absurdity particularly as a contrary interpretation would be adding to the said provision what is not expressly stated or intended, or putting unnecessary strain on that section which strain the said section will be unable to bear. In conclusion, I resolve the lone issue in this appeal against the appellants and hold the considered view that the appeal is without merit whatsoever and deserves to fail”.
                      Conclusion
     If makers of the Nationality law had intended to restrict foreigners when acquiring Cameroon nationality, they could have said so clearly. Reading too much in the section dealing with acquiring Cameroon nationality might be too much for the section to bear. Despite the discrimination in the interpretation, it is not a foregone conclusion that the court will interpret it to get the harmony that is sought.

     The court might claim that there is no absurdity and that the words of the nationality law are clear enough. Perhaps, a Cameroonian with dual nationality is a more serious threat to national security than say an American who also acquires Cameroon nationality. The American might never want to be president so no danger to the top dog.

     Based on the above, I cannot dismiss completely the possibility that the courts in Cameroun might interpret the Nationality law in the discriminatory manner. We still have to wait until a decision on the issue is taken by a superior court in Cameroon.

Dr. Martin Tumasang is a Barrister at law, Advocate/Notary Public/Solicitor, International Arbitrator, Chartered Valuation Surveyor, Principal Quantity Surveyor, Claims Quantum Consultant. He lives in England and he could be reached via email @ Tumasangm@hotmail.com

Sunday, January 5, 2014

Bishop Francis Lysinge: The Courage to Step Aside

The Bishop has defined in practical terms, the true meaning of leadership, in a country held hostage by a gerontocracy. Surely he personifies the leader that Cameroon needs.
                                                                                       By Ekinneh Agbaw-Ebai*


     The decision of Bishop Francis Teke Lysinge to retire from his exalted position as Bishop of Mamfe Diocese, upon reaching the canonical age (75years) for the retirement of bishops on December 28, 2013, speaks of an uncommon courage and humility. By stepping aside and walking away from the ephemeral active Episcopal ministry in favour of a well-deserved retirement; a spiritual life dedicated to prayer, Bishop Lysinge has set a template for true leadership, not only in the spiritual world but in the secular too.

      A prodigally gifted man, Bishop Lysinge is an erudite and well-travelled scholar, whose ebullient stature and convivial nature are ably augmented by his simplicity. He is also an urbane social crusader and motivator with a self-effacing and unassuming style. What’s more? He is tenacious with a magnanimous disposition, but he is not vociferous. Besides his pastoral and intellectual pedigree, he has been a dogged promoter of justice and champion for the poor, and an inspiration to many who have met him. An intellectually sophisticated man of distinction, Bishop Lysinge knows when to quit the stage, and has chosen to leave honorably; when the ovation is loudest.

      This move has, naturally, shocked not only the community of Catholic faithful in Mamfe Diocese, the entire Bamenda Ecclesiastical Province, but even the whole nation. For the reasons that the Bishop was both the spiritual head of the local Church, and pioneer Bishop of Mamfe Diocese, this move cannot but bear in different ways – doctrinal, spiritual and moral implications for the church. Bishops are men of no mean influence. As ecclesiastical authorities, they have their Diocese as their constituency, and as servants in the Lord, they enjoy the powers and privileges that high public office bestows. Besides being men of demonstrable spirituality, they are also men of perceptible moral stamina, champions of faith and instruments of peace and compassion, and defenders of human dignity. In short, Bishops are great men. Being part of this clique carries a great responsibility. This in itself speaks volumes of the prestige, power, authority, and influence that attend this one-of-a-kind office; privileges and appurtenances that would derange the thinking of and entrap most mortals.

      Not so for Bishop Francis Lysinge. His candor in admitting that, “after fourteen years as Bishop of Mamfe, and forty-seven years as a priest, by the grace of God, the Holy Father rightfully thinks that I deserve some rest from active pastoral ministry. I will therefore, be at the service of my bishop, the Most Rev. Andrew Nkea, once I hand over the baton to him upon reaching the canonical age for the retirement of bishops, on the 28th of December 2013” is worthy of commendation and his example is rare, in present day Cameroon; where the mantra is: “he is up, so he must be brought down; he wants my post, so I must destroy him; pull him down and take his place.” Announcing the appointment of his successor in a pastoral letter entitled “Something Beautiful for God”, Bishop Lysinge said: “it was my wish that (Mamfe) Diocese be assigned a Coadjutor who will govern with me for a while to ensure that there is a smooth transition when I turn the canonical age of retirement. From the very beginning of my Episcopal ministry, I have always prayed for a smooth transition so that the work of evangelization in our young diocese of Mamfe continues without any interruption…I did not want to leave things to a vague future after I retire”

      However one looks at it, Bishop Lysinge’s Episcopal retirement is indeed an epochal event. There has not been one in the Mamfe before. It is, therefore, important to emphasize the lessons – spiritual and temporal – to draw from this unusual incident; lessons that are worth commending to all men and women in leadership positions at any level in Cameroon; where the humility to admit to advancing age or failing health is viewed as a sign of weakness. The country is replete with too many ignoble examples of sit-tightism. In contradistinction, Bishop Lysinge had no difficulty recognizing that both the strength of body and mind are necessary to fulfill the episcopal ministry entrusted to him. His popularity as the “Peoples’ Bishop” is a measure of the trust placed on him, his distinct attribute as a leader; his incorruptibility, courage, sincerity, firmness and decisiveness. These traits, highly required of a true leader, are sadly in short supply with Cameroonian leaders. 

     Put in perspective, between a choice to remain in office while still capable of providing effective leadership; and the desire to respect the rules of engagement and stand down for another able shepherd, Bishop Lysinge chose the latter. By putting the common good of Mamfe Diocese above his self-interest, Bishop Lysinge demonstrated that he has conquered the self; indeed, he has waged and won the first and the greatest of all human struggles, without compromising principles. This is the hallmark of greatness. In truth, the work of a bishop is to be a father; responsible to those for whom he cares but at the same time accountable to the Lord for the divine commission given by the Good Shepherd Himself; to be faithful is to be true to the One who is the Way, the Truth and the Life, not seeking personal gain or private fulfillment but always and only what the Lord requires.

      Therefore, the Ministry of a Bishop is not measured in terms of achievements or successes but is understood only in the language of faith, hope and love. Steadfast in faith, inspired by hope, and motivated by love, Bishop Lysinge employed his eloquence and personal charisma to articulate an evangelization campaign that brought the “medicine of mercy” to thousands of Christians and non-believers alike. He was unwavering in this pursuit. An intellectual of no mean order, Bishop Lysinge, read the signs correctly that, after 51 years in the service of the Lord, he is entitled to a well-deserved rest from active episcopalism. Surely he personifies the leader that Cameroon needs.

      The appointment of Andrew Nkea as Coadjutor Bishop of Mamfe Diocese could not have been more proverbial. However, among those who have known Bishop Nkea or followed his career, the appointment was not a surprise. In Bishop Lysinge’s own words, Bishop Nkea: “is my spiritual son, having been his spiritual director in the Major Seminary in Bambui. As an efficient administrator and canon lawyer, he will definitely lead our diocese along the beautiful path of God. It is a happy coincidence that the then Bishop of Buea, Most Rev. Pius Awa, charged the Bishop-Elect, then his Secretary and Chancellor of the Diocese of Buea, to prepare for my Episcopal ordination in Mamfe on the 21st of  April 1999. He read the bull of my appointment by the Holy Father at that mass. How mysterious are the ways of God! Who could tell that fourteen years later, the one reading the bull will take over from me? How mysterious are the ways of God! How unfathomable his ways!”

     As admirers wait to see how the new Bishop would engage his flock, Bishop Nkea should be reminded that being a Bishop lends him a transcendent voice that translates his position to a call to duty. The trickling effects of his profound intellect, cultural intelligence, motivating power, and solicitude, as well as the influence of his new position should be harnessed to resolve the hydra-headed problems bedeviling not just Mamfe Diocese, but the entire country. In practical terms, this would entail turning his lectern into a bully-pulpit to fight not only for the souls of his congregation, but for the cause of all Cameroonians; speaking truth to power, when and where necessary.

     As the first Bishop of Mamfe Diocese is celebrated in impressive words and colors - a well-deserved celebration - the question for the Catholic faithful and Cameroonians is: what lessons can be learned from Bishop Lysinge? His retirement signals a new direction in the Mamfe Diocese, as well as introduces a new value into, not just the Diocesan leadership, but leadership everywhere. Deriving from this, it may be said that any man worth the honor of leading at any level must have the humility, the courage, and the selflessness to, in a manner of speaking, walk away from it all. It is in this context then that it can be said that, like great men who define real greatness by challenging the spirit of their age, Bishop Francis Lysinge has, by his decision to retire, altered the spirit of the age in Cameroon where a gerontocracy has taken the nation hostage. And in doing so, he defined in practical terms, the true meaning of leadership. The lessons of his episcopal ministry ought to be paramount and imbibed by present and future Cameroonian leaders.

*Ekinneh Agbaw-Ebai is a Public Intellectual and graduate of Harvard University John F. Kennedy School of Government, where he was Managing Editor of the Harvard Journal of African-American Public Policy. A former Research Analyst for Freedom House, he is a Consultant and lives in Boston, Massachusetts, USA.


The Bushfallers: The Rise of a New Breed of Cameroonians

 


  
By Emmanuel Konde
      The years between 1975 and 1991 something happened in Cameroon that transformed the generations after into creatures radically different from the before generations.  This work is about the generations after.  It traces their development through the prism of Cameroon’s political history. As the first generation of Cameroonians born under the United Republic of Cameroon, their character reflects the political changes of their country.  They attained maturity with the political maturity of Cameroon.  

                                                 Prologue

      A new kind of Cameroonian, either derogatively or approvingly designated as bushfallers in his native land, was conceived in the 1970s by a variety of social forces that intersected and then converged to give social birth to this formidable breed in the early 1990s.  These forces, mainly political and economic, also contributed to the inauguration of a quasi-multiparty political system in the erstwhile single-party state of Cameroon, and, accordingly unleashed a new ethos of aggressiveness among Cameroonians hitherto known for their passivity as a people who were always seen but seldom heard. Bushfallers, the human product of these forces of social change, are not only smart, determined, daring, calculating, enterprising, at once assertive and aggressive, but also seemingly unstoppable.  There seems to be nothing that this edition of bushfallers cannot accomplish if they set their minds on it.  These are the new exports of Cameroon to the world.  They are out to make money, the one thing that sets them apart from many generations before, and the one and only thing that compelled them to venture out of the Land of Promise into foreign lands far and wide.

     Markedly different from their antecedents who traveled abroad for various reasons, the driving force behind this driven breed is money. Again, unlike their antecedents, bushfallers never forget their roots.  They are first and foremost Cameroonians, nationalists of sorts, and totally devoid of tribal sentiment; they love their country, eschew tribal affiliations, are determined to make an indelible mark on the history of Cameroon, and to that end are making magic, literally, by their own exertions.  This new breed is transforming Cameroon from the coastal town of Limbe through Kumba to the Bamenda hinterlands.  Former shanty towns are being remade by the remittances of bushfallers.  Here and there marvelous buildings sprout from the soil like the corn crop. Indeed, even in the Bassa quartier Nkong Mondo in Douala, Francophone bushfaller wealth filtering into Cameroon from Gabon, Côte d’Ivoire, France, etc., is wreaking wonders there to the utter amazement of Bamileke merchants who once thought of the Nkong Mondo Bassa youths as lazy and un-enterprising. 

     Never before has Cameroon beheld a marvel like the one being wrought almost everywhere in the country by bushfallers.  It is improbable that such a breath-taking marvel could again be fashioned in the future; neither shall the country ever again behold a breed in the likeness of bushfallers. This newness,   this transformation of the Cameroonian being is novel as it is unique and epochal.  

     Bushfaller wealth is also transforming the lives of many in their respective families, clans, tribes, and the entire country. Because of the special qualities of bushfallers, this breed constitutes the wave of the future of Cameroon. What is not clear at this time, however, is whether this new wave of change represented by bushfallers portends good or ill for Cameroon.  Admittedly, the ultimate end of “bushfallerism” in Cameroon is a prognosis too premature to make at this juncture.  Time will, however, tell.

     The emphasis on bushfallers should not be misconstrued as a denigration of non-bushfaller achievements; for, we recognize that bushfallers were assisted by their older brothers and sisters who either preceded them to Mbengue Europa and Mbengue Amerika, or labored in the Fatherland to ensure the advancement of their brethren.  But the visible achievements of the Cameroonians who first ventured abroad simply fade into insignificance when compared to those of bushfallers. On this conclusion I stake my reputation as an observer of social change in Cameroon..

      I write as a social philosopher and student of history, whose task is to interpret and explain the workings of the social order as accurately as possible. I examine how individuals and groups behave in society; I analyze the actions of individuals and aggregations and draw general conclusions from these about society.  From this vantage point, I am able to discern a striking social phenomenon that has been unfolding before our very own eyes during the past 16 years or so.  This phenomenon is now taking concrete form.  Its locus of incubation is the Fatherland, Cameroon.  Although there was in fact a commingling of variables that ushered in this bushfaller phenomenon, I have decided to isolate a few pivotal ones that influenced the making of this new breed.
     My last teenage escapade in Cameroon happened in Victoria, present-day Limbe, in 1975.  We were in Bay Hotel one Sunday afternoon dancing to Makossa during “Tea Time” when a scuffle ensued between one local boy and a military man over a girl.  I was inside gyrating to the deafening blast of a medley of Toto Guillaume and  the Black Styl, and did not witness the scuffle.  The soldier carried a pistol, which he pulled out.  He did not fire a single shot.  But the mere sight of a small gun sent more than 100 civilians running helter-skelter for dear life.  I was one of those civilians, and those were the waning years of Ahmadou Ahidjo’s Cameroon when some contemporary bushfallers were either toddlers or yet-to-be-born.  Fast forward to 1991, sixteen years later during the teenage years of our bushfallers now come of age.  We behold them battling armed soldiers with fists and stones during “Operation Ghost Town” under the auspices of John Fru Ndi.  From all apparent indications, a lot had happened in Cameroon that created something of a generational gulf between my teenage years and those of our bushfallers.  It is that something, which distinguishes the new breed of Cameroonian, that this work promises to unravel.

     The years between 1975 and 1991 something happened in Cameroon that transformed the generations after into creatures radically different from the before generations.  This work is about the generations after.  It traces their development through the prism of Cameroon’s political history. As the first generation of Cameroonians born under the United Republic of Cameroon, their character reflects the political changes of their country.  They attained maturity with the political maturity of Cameroon.  When in the early-1990s Operation Ghost Town released Cameroonians from the dictatorship of the Cameroon People’s Democratic Movement (CPDM), an offshoot of Ahidjo’s Cameroon National Union (CNU), the children of the Unitary State were the foot soldiers of this struggle and contributed to the making of the new epoch President Paul Biya aptly called the “New Deal Society”. Born in chains, these children were released from their chains by the promises of Biya’s New Deal Society, which opened up the closed society of Ahidjo’s “Old Oder” and gave vent to Fru Ndi’s “Operation Ghost Town”.

     If Operation Ghost Town provided them freedom domestically, the forces of globalization extended this freedom internationally. By the late 1990s, the would-be bushfallers were looking outward to the larger world for those things that the sagging Cameroon economy could not offer them.  Once abroad, their intermittent visits to Cameroon, which revealed behaviors, attitudes, and showmanship never before seen in Cameroon, won them the sobriquet bushfallers—those who fall bush (chappia bush), work (plant), and after harvesting come home to show off their newly acquired….

     The Bushfallers: Rise of a New Breed of Cameroonians is the story of their origins, growth, and transformative power.  As chronicler of the compelling story, that follows, I cannot help it but echo the sentiment of American sociologist C. Wright Mills: “I will try to be objective; I do not claim to be detached,” for, I am an offspring of Cameroon and can therefore not pretend detachment by any stretch of the imagination.
     This exegesis is an exposé of bushfallers cast within the context of some defining moments in the history of Cameroon from 1960 to the present. It does not attempt to pass judgment on this new breed because they defy social conventions and their proper place in the social order is yet to be defined.  The narrative style employed in this expose is the motif, drawn from music, whereby certain musical patterns recur time and time again throughout the piece.  In the case of this work, instead of musical patterns the focus of emphasis is on ideas, which are reiterated over and over again at different points and in different chapters of this work.  This narrative strategy is adopted in order to drive home the significance of the rise of bushfallers and the role that history seems to have pre-determined for them.  But, will they defy historical imperative?   



 

Thursday, January 2, 2014

Cameroon: The Challenges of New Year 2014

With serious economic, infrastructural and security challenges to contend with, Cameroonians no longer expect the scandalous and profligate posturing that dominated the country’s leadership in 2013.

                                                 By Ekinneh Agbaw-Ebai*

     New Year Day is a day to rejoice and congratulate each other for witnessing another calendar year; and for many Cameroonians, it is a day to celebrate the hope that survival imposes on the country, even in an atmosphere of poverty and widespread lamentation. It is also a day to cast an introspective look into personal, corporate and national affairs in the year just gone by, to take stock and to chart a new course for the year ahead.This past year was strewn with many booby traps, both literally and metaphorically. On the whole, 2013 saw Cameroon developing into a nation in conflict with itself, a nation living in outright contradiction to its declared development objectives.

     For the umpteenth time, Cameroonians have had, at the turn of each year, the assurances of thePresident that better times are at hand. For that many number of times, Cameroonians have ended up with shattered hopes, broken promises and failed commitments. From all indications, it would appear that Cameroonians have been swindled again by their own government. In fact, not only have situations not improved, they have actually deteriorated. Most of the promises made, if not all, have gone unfulfilled.The Biya regime continues to harvest corruption scandals, with half-hearted pursuit of high profile culprits of audacious corruption. Whichever way Cameroonians turn, they are confronted with the overarching presence of pervasive corruption and societal decay.

     With serious economic, infrastructural and security challenges to contend with, the attention of the country’s leaders was in the course of the year 2013 often consumed by vaulting ambition, pursued with intricate permutations, manipulations and maneuvering. The Senate, Legislative and Municipal election saw a vicious, if not subtle hold-up of the electoral process whereby tired old men tottering on the borders of senile decay, were recycled with impunity!To add salt to an already festering injury, the youths were told to go and “wait for their turn.” This, indeed, is unacceptable. Even if the age of these gerontocrats is no problem, what about the age of their ideas?

     What the country deserves at this critical point is a crop of leaders that are endowed with the gift of steady application, imbued with the ability to control events rather than drift with the tides, and who in range of vision and depth of conception, tower above their contemporaries. Cameroon needs leaders of iron resolve, indomitable courage and sharp intellect with acute and exceptional sense of history to lead the people out of the doldrums. Such people abound in their numbers in this country but are choked by warped and corrupt recruitment processes, the major albatross of the country. Something, afterall, is wrong with a process which makes a few persons, in certain offices, or with some dubious connections; see it as their exclusive right to nominate people for appointment to public offices.

     As a New Year begins again, Cameroonian leaders must stop and think just where the country is headed. Does the experience of the last 30 years aggregate to development in a land so abundantly blessed but so deeply violated and desecrated? Pathological lust for power and greed for money have rendered purposeful leadership prostrate. It has become more and more apparent that the fortune of this country is confiscated by those concerned with maintaining and expanding their private economic and political estates, hence whichever way the dice falls, there is a sense of foreboding thatpeace will soon go into exile, and prosperity will be long in coming.

     The colossal waste and looting in government makes it now obvious that Cameroon’s problem, truly, is not money but where to spend it.The families and cronies of public office holders have constituted themselves into patronage cartels at whose disposal alone the public treasuryis placed and they alone decide who gets what. Vanity, of course, rules and their lifestyle is so opulent and extravagant in ways that are highly offensive to public sensibility.Large-scale looting, misappropriation of public funds and sundry acts of impunity anda culture of waste has taken root, fuelling an unmanageable cost of governance and, consequently, poor service to the people.

     It is so bad that, untested hands are appointed into sensitive public offices. The refrain is that the best of Cameroonians are outside the government. This tragedy is a vicious cycle: The collapse of businesses and poor economic environment due to poor political and economic decisions have made government and politics a major and most rewarding source of livelihood, the only thriving business, the surest way of climbing to the top with little or no sweat. Those who failed in business, in their education and some who at one time or the other, contributed to the economic downturn of the nation continue to be recycled in political offices giving them the opportunity to perpetuate their failure in the affairs of the nation. The result is what obtains today: widespread ineptitude in the body politic. No country, after all, can rise above the level of its workforce, especially at the decision-making or leadership level, hence the parlous state of the nation.

     The slogan of Vision 2035 remains for many critical minds a huge joke, a wild and idle prediction of the place of Cameroon’s economy by year 2035 on the global scale. The country’s path to greatness will be defined by the choices it makes today. Those who have had the primary responsibility to lead this country to greatness have often paid lip service to a nation; one, united and indivisible. Cameroon is nowhere near its potential; rather, it is a jungle to be plundered and violated with impunity.The bigger picture of the Cameroonian national mosaic demands the undivided attention of leaders who, of their own choosing, have come forward to govern. That mosaic must encompass the multi-dimensions of nation-building - education, healthcare, the economy, security, social services. These must be pursued simultaneously in an environment of social justice and equity, and it is what democracy is all about. Where any aspect is left unattended, development becomes stunted. We cannot claim to develop when access to jobs is effectively closed to the teeming products of the education system. We cannot develop when leaders go abroad for painkillers and surgery, rather than build functional health facilities at home.

     As Cameroonians enter a New Year, they expect of their leaders a change of heart, a resolve to put in hard work in legislation, planning, execution and oversight and accountability. What Cameroonians no longer expect is the scandalous and profligate posturing that dominates the country’s leadership today.Without the hope of a better tomorrow, life would be sterile. The experiences of 2013 serve as a reminder that justice as a primary condition of human existence remains a critical undercurrent of the nation’s travails. Cameroonians can only continue to embrace the peace, which the President often talks about so thoughtlessly, in an environment of justice and equity. They have no other country but this one to call their own. If so-called leaders aspire for peace and development, they must embrace justice. The country’s leaders must renew their pledge to diligently assume a leadership anchored on integrity, principles and exemplary self-sacrifice. Cameroon will stand or fall on account of how it tackles corruption. On this note, I wish all Cameroonians a Happy New Year!


*Ekinneh Agbaw-Ebai is a Public Intellectual and graduate of Harvard University John F. Kennedy School of Government, where he was Managing Editor of the Harvard Journal of African-American Public Policy. A former Research Analyst for Freedom House, he is a Consultant and lives in Boston, Massachusetts, USA

Leasing Vs. Purchasing an Automobile



After reading the last paragraph of my reply to Sango Samuel-King Etongwe on "Njangi", a few folks called me directly, asking why I think leasing an automobile is a better option or choice than outright purchasing one. Because these fellows were very satisfied with my response, I thought it would be important to share the same information with you, for better decision making in 2014 and beyond.

     I do not know much about automobile sales in Europe, Asia or Africa, but if you live in the U.S, there are 4 ways you can acquire any vehicle or mode of transportation;

1) Leasing

2) Cash Purchase

3) Purchasing through Financing (OPM)

4) Stealing/Carjacking????

I do not recommend option #4 because you might end up in prison or getting killed. So, my discussion will focus on the first 3 options.

1) Leasing.

     When you lease an automobile or any other commodity for that matter, you are agreeing to use it for a specific interval or period of time, the duration of which is embedded in the contract. In the case of an automobile, the contract will include the monthly payments, residual value or future market value of the machine, mileage requirements, term of lease to include termination date and other conditions, etc.
    
You can also have a close ended or open ended lease, but that is another matter. However, in leasing, you will always have the following options to exercise during or at the end of the lease agreement;

a) You can purchase the vehicle at the end of the Lease period or before.

b) You can trade in the vehicle for another one.

c) You can sell the automobile to a third party and use the proceeds from the sale to pay off any balance owed.

d) You can also return the vehicle to the dealer at the end of the lease.

     Most people are only familiar with the last option, i.e. return the vehicle. Hence, they fail to take advantage of the other options available to them. This lack of information compounds the misconception the general public has about leasing.

2) Purchase.

There are two primary methods involved in "purchasing" an automobile.

a) Cash Payment.

b) Financing.

2(a) Cash Payment.

     Here is when you have decided on what vehicle make and model you want, and you do not desire having a monthly "car note" or payment. So, you use your hard earned money, to pay cash for the automobile. As soon as you make the total payment in cash or check, the vehicle becomes YOURS, because you own the Title, free and clear. And if the cash you have on hand at the time of the transaction exceeds $10,000.00, then your purchase has to be reported to IRS as a security measure against "money laundering" or what have you....

2(b) Financing or Loan.

     Here, you decide that you do not want to pay cash or cannot afford paying cash for the automobile of your choice. So, you elect to use "Other People's Money" or OPM, via the Finance option. You either borrow money from your Bank or Credit Union or any other financial institution made available to you by the dealership. You will agree to pay interest (APR) on the loan you take and that increases the cost of the automobile at the "back-end". And the cost of the loan or APR will depend of your credit rating and/or market conditions. The higher your credit score, the lower the interest rate you'll have to pay, and vice versa. Poor credit ranking means higher risk for Banks. Very bad credit rating or lower score can stop or prevent a "cash strapped person" from acquiring a decent mode of transportation. However, dealers have devised creative ways to give folks "second chances" at extremely high interest rates, e.g. "Buy Here, Pay Here" or "Owner Financing."

Question #1; So why is Leasing better than Purchase?

Answer;

A) Unlike a piece of Real Estate, an automobile is a depreciating asset. The longer you own and keep it, the lower its market value. That is not the case with a house. In proper finance management or asset allocation, you want to own an appreciating asset but, lease depreciating assets if you have to, and invest the difference in savings.

B) Leases are generally less expensive in terms of monthly payments than Financing. A good negotiation can save you between $75.00 to about $100.00 on a lease transaction. That nets to about $1000.00 annually. And although you pay "money factor" on leasing, when converted the rate is generally lower than what you would pay in APR. The reason why leasing is less expensive is primarily because you are only paying for the duration of the lease agreement, as opposed to the "life" of the automobile. It's akin to eating and paying for 2 slices of Deluxe Pizza from Mellow Mushroom, instead of paying for a whole pizza that you may not want. You only pay for what you need.

C) Your automobile is under the manufacturer's warranty during the period of the lease. The most service you'll do on the vehicle is change the oil and gas it up. Most power train warranties are 3/36 and bumper-bumper=5/60. So, if you lease a vehicle for 3 years @ 12000km/yr, then you are completely covered under warranty for the duration of the lease. That alone is an attractive feature.

D) Most leases come with ''gap insurance" as part of the package. The leasing company seeks to protect its "asset" so it ties "gap" to the deal, in the event of an accident, God forbid.

E) In purchasing, you have only 2 options to exercise, (a) sell, (b) trade. Otherwise, you're stuck with a depreciating asset, which may eventually become a liability.

F) If you owned a business, and leased the automobile in your company's name, you get to make tax deductions at the end of each fiscal year. You can deduct all your or most of your payments on the lease, but you may want to consult with your accountant to be sure about how that works.

Question #2; But I do not own the vehicle when I lease it. What happens to the money I have paid?

Answer.

    That is a normal question from people who don't understand the concept of leasing. You pay for the time you use the automobile and still reserve the right to exercise all other options available to you as aforementioned. Residual value means future market value of the product, subtracting what you've already paid. It's like putting a down payment on something to limit your "financial liability" or "obligation".

     On the other hand and for starters, when you purchase an automobile through the second option, e.g. Financing (OPM), you do NOT "own" the vehicle until the 60th or 72nd payment is made, that is if the financing is for 5 or 6 years. In a Title holding State such as Kansas, you are issued a Title with a Lien on it, and the Lien is only released after the final payment is made. In most other states, you do not get a Title, so the vehicle does not belong to you until you make the last or final payment.

     If you lived in Atlanta-Ga. for instance, where the city is spread out and you drive approximately 20,000 miles a year, then the damn machine will have more than 100,000 miles by the time you assume full ownership of the vehicle after 5 or 6 years or 60 to 72 payments. That is the age of a normal vehicle in terms of mileage. Now, what do you think your vehicle will be worth, with the meter reading 100,000 miles? Check with Kelly Blue Book. The bottom line is that nobody wants to hold onto a depreciating asset at a time when it is turning into a liability.

Question #3; If I pay Cash, then The vehicle is mine and I can do whatever I want with it. What's wrong with that?

Answer; Sounds great, but here is the problem;

     You drive that new automobile off the dealership lot, make a wrong turn and get hit. You will not receive the same amount of money you paid for it from the insurance company. You will be short by at least 3 grand. That is how fast the thing depreciates. Secondly, if you decided to sell the vehicle after 2 weeks of purchase, because something came up and you needed cash and fast, you will not get the $30,000.00 you paid for it. The most you'll get will be $20,000.00 to $25,000.00, because at that point, it is a second hand or used automobile and the value drops like lead. Automobiles are depreciating assets, and the value decreases rapidly during the first few years. Thirdly, if you did not buy extended service contract or warranty upfront, you will incur additional cost in repairs when the baby gets old and that is when the liability factor kicks in.

     For the above reasons and more, I strongly recommend the Leasing option to a majority of my clients who desire to drive new vehicles.. In most cases I recommend the purchase of "second hand" automobiles, especially Lease Returns, because they are cost effective ad well taken care of. Auto Auctions are also good places to shop for great automobile bargains.

     At this juncture, I'm available to answer any questions that our readers may have on this subject, cognizant of the fact that there are many here who may disagree with my position on "Leasing versus Purchasing". And if I do not know the right answer, I promise to find out from more knowledgeable folks in the industry. That is why forums like these are important. They offer all of us an opportunity to share our opinions on important subjects. This is a very extensive topic that cannot be exhausted in one posting. But I hope I have made my case to your satisfaction. Whenever you can, please use the information contained here and remember that an "educated or informed consumer is often a very satisfied customer or buyer."


Dr. Sam Esale is a Senior Partner with Invictus Afrika Consulting Group headquartered in Atlanta, Georgia. For your consulting businesses please, visit our website at www.invictusafrika.net  and learn more about us. Also visit www.iicfip.org  for more information about IICFIP.

Sunday, December 29, 2013

Christmas and Cameroon's Redemption

   Christmas and Cameroon’s Redemption

Beyond the festivities of Christmas, Cameroonian Christians are once again challenged to live up to the core values of their religion, and impact positively on their socio-cultural and political environment.
                                        By Ekinneh Agbaw-Ebai*
     The birth of Jesus Christ, which is celebrated every December 25, is the portentous event of the Incarnation, from which Christianity draws its essence. Christians the world over, mark the birth of the Son of God and the Savior of mankind, whose spectacular life of virtue, revolutionary teaching and sacrificial death on the Cross of Calvary, form the basis of the over two thousand year-old Christian religion. Even in a world overrun by secularism and materialism and other social forces impacting negatively on religion and morality, a world witnessing an inexorable decline in Christian values and Christian worship especially in Western industrialized societies, the continued influence of Jesus Christ in a global context is unmistakable.

     Across the globe, Christmas has come to be associated with the festive spirit, family reunions and the celebration of family life and friendship with the exchange of greetings, visits and gifts. It is that time of the year when many are inspired to stretch out the hand of fellowship and solidarity in charity and thanksgiving to all who have survived the stresses and the strains of the passing year. The legend of St. Nicholas, the patron saint of all generous people played out in the form of Father Christmas or Santa Claus, has always excited the curiosity of children, while orphanages, hospitals and prisons will often witness a boost in charity visits at this time.

     For Cameroonians, however, Christmas 2013 brings to a close a year of shocks and pains and blood and tears. Cameroonians have been struggling to cope with bad governance, decrepit social infrastructure, worsening economic fortunes and widespread social insecurity. And as the year draws to a close, many are counting their losses with a fair dose of stoicism and characteristic hope. Given the terrible scenario playing out in the country, manifested in mass poverty, high corruption in government, gross official recklessness and near zero governance, this Christmas should serve as a poignant reminder to those in power, to embrace service to humanity and improvement of people’s welfare as a central theme of their governance activities. This, in any event, is enjoined of them in the 1996 Constitution, which Mr. President swore to uphold.

     In spite of the agony and the social chaos that have endured in the country, however, the celebratory spirit of the Cameroonian will not be dampened. The incurable optimism in the Cameroonian; their resilience and undying spirit, now obviously stretched to the limit, is what appears to have secured the peaceful quiet that prevails amid the subsisting trauma of life in the country. Perhaps in the view of many, Christmas is too important a milestone in the Christian life cycle to be abandoned to the vagaries of disoriented and misguided politicians and robbers in government who are in the habit of distributing food items to the poor during Christmas, as if the beneficiaries have no need to eat outside of the month of December. Ideally, government should do better to embark on measures to empower such poor people to feed themselves all year round. Many Christians will go out to worship and to celebrate, if only to demonstrate to their so-called leaders that they do indeed have a substantial stake in this country, and that despite the wholesale plunder of the treasury, they cannot and will not be denied the conduct of their religious obligations and festivities.

     The Cameroonian condition has taken on a life of its own, however, somber such life. The mindless looting that is going on in the country in the name of governance, with telling outcomes in mass poverty and collateral damage, has become an embarrassing trademark of public office. Cameroon’s social conundrum today is exacerbated by the heightened incidence of corruption and obscene display of stolen wealth by public officials without due regard for the majority of citizens who continue to wallow in poverty and misery. The result has been rising criminality by unemployed youths who have resorted to armed robbery, such that travelling home for Christmas has become risky and daunting as weathering the siege of war. The government has dropped the ball allowing bike riders to take virtually every principal city in the country hostage; all in the name of survival. The bend skin menace (for want of a better expression) has been allowed to fester for too long and has now degenerated into some kind of a low-intensity insurgency against state authority. It has gotten to a stage where the government is now helpless and clueless on what to do to address the issue. This is an affront on the government and the people of Cameroon that is unacceptable.

     Christmas is, however, the proclamation of good news. It is a celebration of joy and of hope. The Christ, whose birth is marked every December 25, has given the world a roadmap to abundant life, peace and prosperity. Taken seriously and applied in our individual and corporate lives, the values preached by Jesus, namely sacrificial love, justice, compassion, leadership by service, forgiveness, humility and purity of heart, will transform Cameroon for the better. The disposition towards crass materialism, excessive wealth accumulation and blind pursuit of pleasure is clearly at variance with the spirit of this holy day.

     And so beyond the festivities of Christmas, Christians in Cameroon are once again challenged to live up to the core values of their religion, and impact positively on their socio-cultural and political environment. There is need for sober reflection on the moral imperatives of the political and economic choices before the nation. The values which symbolize the life of Christ – love, truth, justice, humility, service, self-sacrifice, forgiveness, remain elusive as Cameroonians struggle for the soul of the nation. Incumbent and aspiring Cameroonian leaders must abandon the path of selfishness, greed, primitive accumulation and inordinate ambitions if the country would prosper. Christians and non-Christians alike must embrace the higher value of sacrificial leadership that make for lasting peace and prosperity.

Merry Christmas and a more prosperous New Year 2014; to all Cameroonians.


*Ekinneh Agbaw-Ebai is a Public Intellectual and graduate of Harvard University John F. Kennedy School of Government, where he was Managing Editor of the Harvard Journal of African-American Public Policy. A former Research Analyst for Freedom House, he is a Consultant and lives in Boston, Massachusetts, USA.











    The Legal Aid Commission (Commission d'Assistance Judiciaire) in Cameroon     In Cameroon, the Legal Aid Commission (Commissio...